Challenges with Conducting Tailings Dam Breach Assessments

Challenges with Conducting Tailings Dam Breach Assessments

Author: Alana Shewan, Anna Akkerman, Violeta Martin
Conference: 85th Annual Meeting of International Commission on Large Dams
Date: July 3-7, 2017

ABSTRACT
Following the recent tailings dam breaches at Mount Polley, Canada, and Samarco, Brazil, the mining industry and regulatory agencies worldwide increased the demand for tailings dam breach analyses and flood inundation mapping. The results of such studies are used to determine the hazard classification of a dam through the assessment of dam failure consequences, to support emergency preparedness and response planning, and to inform environmental assessments. Dam breach studies involve the selection of a dam failure mode and appropriate hydrologic conditions, the approximation of the breach size, the estimation of the volumes of released tailings and water, and the modelling and mapping of the runout pattern of released materials. There is considerable uncertainty in each step of the analysis, which combined with the lack of a standardized approach for completing such studies, necessitates that practitioners rely on experience and sound professional judgement to conduct the studies and assess the results. In this paper, we review some of our recent experiences with tailings dam breach assessments and discuss challenges encountered and lessons learned for various case studies, including selecting credible failure modes, selecting appropriate hydrologic parameters, determining the range of possible breach parameters, and estimating the volumes of released tailings.

 

Download the full technical paper.

Download

 

Recent Insights

May 2023
Is the Implementation of Dry Stacking for Tailings Storage Increasing? A Southern African Perspective
February 2023
Canadian Consulting Engineer's Lifetime Achievement Awards: Jeremy Haile
February 2023
Geotechnical Characterization of Collapsible Salty Sands Subjected to Monotonic and Cyclic Loadings – A Case Study for Areas with High Seismicity
November 2022
Application of the 3D Limit Equilibrium Method in Tailings Dam Breach Analysis
November 2022
Evaluation of Tailings Behaviour for Dam Breach Assessments
November 2022
Tailings Improvement by Stress-Densification from Waste Rock Capping
November 2022
Transforming Tailings Management Systems toward Alignment with the GISTM: A Case History
October 2022
Managing Excessive Pit Wall Deformation of Weak Rock Mass
October 2022
State-of-the-art Method for Estimating Long-term Hydroclimatic Conditions for Tailing Dam Water Management and Dam Safety Planning
August 2022
Observed Subsidence Progression at New Afton Mine in Response to Lift 1 Mining
June 2022
Hydrometric Monitoring and Effluent Discharge Mixing in Challenging Natural Conditions
May 2022
Inundation Modelling of Non-Newtonian Tailings Dam Breach Outflows
May 2022
Video: Tailings Management Compliancy Picks Up Momentum
May 2022
A Catch up with...Richard Elmer
February 2022
Engineer of Record Services for Tailings Facilities
November 2021
Knight Piésold's Projects Commended at Prestigious Awards
November 2021
Advances in Ensuring Tailings Dam Safety
November 2021
Gearing Up for Growth in Zambia
October 2021
Climate Change Effects on Rainfall Extremes and Implications for Highway Drainage Structures
October 2021
Knight Piésold, aliado de la minería sustentable